eat. To thank our friend Alan who got us half-price hotels during our recent trip to Britain and Dublin, Cathy and I decided to cook him a fancy English dinner. Knowing his fondness for “gourmet” food, we decided to impress him with a home-cooked beef Wellington—a fillet of beef covered with pâté and
duxelle mushrooms, and then wrapped in pastry and baked.
the finished product(with roasted potatoes and haricots verts)The dish is named for the famous
Duke, though no one is exactly sure why—perhaps simply because he had a fondness for it. Beef Wellington became all the rage in the States in the 1960s, and has the reputation of being difficult to make. (I’ve had it twice in restaurants, and both times the meat was overcooked.) We found, however, that if you simply follow the recipe carefully, it’s not hard to make—but it is somewhat time-consuming. We used the recipe from
Gourmet magazine (with certain changes).
The night before the dinner, I made the
duxelles, which is basically a mushroom spread. Take a pound of mushrooms, several shallots, and a tablespoon of fresh thyme (stems removed), chop them coarsely, and then mince them all together in a food processor (don’t over-mix or it will turn completely to mush!)

Dump it all into a large skillet, add several tablespoons of butter, and cook the mixture over a medium heat. The mushrooms will first expel their moisture, and then the liquid will cook away.

When most of the liquid is gone, add about a half cup of cooking sherry, and continue to cook the mixture until this has mostly cooked off.

Add more butter to taste,

and then finish the
duxelles with about two tablespoons of truffle oil (or finely chopped truffles), and S&P to taste.

Chill the
duxelles until needed for the beef.
The trick to having a properly cooked beef Wellington is to roast it in two stages. The second baking is mostly just for the pastry; the meat will only cook a little more. The morning of the dinner, Cathy did the pre-baking of the fillet of beef. She covered the top of the fillet with thin slices of lard, and tied them on with string.
photo: Cathy Kriege(you can see the block of lard in the background)Let the larded fillet sit on the counter until it is at room temperature, and then roast it in the middle of a preheated 400° F oven for 25-30 minutes (it should register 120° or a little under on a meat thermometer).

Let the fillet cool completely. Reserve the meat juices for the sauce, and discard (or use for something else) the fat in the baking pan. Make sure you remove the string!
The next step is coating the fillet with the pâté and
duxelles. Take ½ pound of room-temperature pâté (we used duck liver, but you could use any kind you like) and blend it with a quarter pound of softened butter.

Spread this pâté mixture over the top and sides of the fillet,

and then spread the
duxelles on top of the pâté.

Now it’s time to wrap it in the pastry. We used store-bought frozen (and thawed) puff pastry. Roll it out so it’s big enough to cover the meat, reserving a little of the pastry for garnishes.

Flip the fillet carefully on its back onto the center of the pastry dough,

and then wrap it as you would with wrapping paper, brushing the parts that meet with lightly-beaten egg white.


Turn the wrapped fillet onto a shallow, greased baking pan, and brush the top and sides with an egg wash of lightly-beaten yolk and a little water.

Cut out some garnishes from the reserved dough (cookie cutters would work for this),

and place them on the top of the fillet and brush the garnishes with more egg wash.

Put the fillet in the fridge to let it chill until time to cook—for at least an hour. While it’s chilling, make the sauce.
In a saucepan, mix the reserved meat juices (we had hardly any) and ½ cup of Madeira until it has reduced by a fourth. Dissolve two teaspoons of arrowroot in one tablespoon of water, and whisk this into the mixture in the saucepan, along with a ½ cup of beef broth, and either 2 tablespoons chopped truffles or 2 T truffle oil. Let this cook for five minutes at under a boil, whisking occasionally, until it thickens, and then season with S&P.
The sauce can sit until time for service, when it should be reheated. (This is the reason to use
arrowroot rather than cornstarch, as sauces thickened with cornstarch don’t reheat well.)

About an hour before you want to eat the beef Wellington, put the chilled fillet in the middle of a preheated 400° F oven, and bake for 30-40 minutes, until the pastry dough is golden brown, and the internal temperature reads between 120° (rare) and 130° (medium rare)—note that it will continue to cook a little after you take it out of the oven. After about 30 minutes, ours registered only 100°, and the pastry was still pale:

After about 40 minutes, it was done. Let it stand for 15 minutes, and then slice it and set it on a serving platter:

As you can see from the photo at the top of this post, the beef was perfectly cooked—nice and rare! Drizzle the sauce on the pieces after they have been plated up.
Here is a list of the ingredients, for shopping purposes:
a 3 ½ pound fillet of beet, tied with thin sheets of lard
1 pound mushrooms
several shallots
fresh thyme
1 cup cooking sherry or Madeira
4 T truffle oil or chopped truffles
about ½ pound unsalted butter
1 large egg, separated
1 pound puff pastry
2 t arrowroot
½ cup beef broth